Stay at Our Amish Country Inn in Indiana

That Pretty Place Bed & Breakfast is like a breath of fresh air for travelers looking for lodging in the Shipshewana area.

Our bed and breakfast inn, is located in the heart of Amish Country in Middlebury, Indiana. With over 1000 ft. of frontage along the popular Pumpkinvine Nature Trail. Come and enjoy our country roads, via car or bike, while taking in the beauty and lifestyle of the Amish community. Experience the seclusion of our quiet country setting on 37 acres with walking/biking trails along the old Pumpkinvine Railroad bike trail, including a stocked pond for fishing.

Take a comfortable walk through our woods, leading you to the famous Das Dutchman Essenhaus Restaurant and Gift Shops. The well-known Shipshewana Flea Market is just seven miles away. Middlebury’s Spring Meadow, an 18-hole golf course, is less than a mile away. Notre Dame Football, South Bend Silverhawks, and the College Football Hall of Fame in South Bend are less than an hour away.

Online booking is available or call us at 574-825-3021. Our main house accommodations include five guestrooms, including the Honeymoon Suite, which features a heart-shaped Jacuzzi tub. We can’t wait to see you!

Room Rates

Main House

  • Room 1 – $95.00-$105.00
  • Room 2  – $95.00-$105.00
  • Room 3 – $95.00-$105.00
  • Room 4 – $95.00-$105.00
  • Honeymoon Suite Main House – $115.00-$125

Serenity Suites

  • Serenity Suite 1 (Queen) –  $135.00-$145.00
  • Serenity Suite 2 (Queen) –  $135.00-$145.00
  • Serenity Suite 3 (King) –  $145.00-$155.00
  • Serenity Suite 4 (Queen) –  $135.00-$145.00

SERENITY SUITES

Our newest addition to our beautiful bed and breakfast property is Serenity Suites. A separate building set in the woods, Serenity Suites features four spacious guestrooms. Three rooms feature a queen-size bed, and one room has a king-size bed. Each room also has a sleeper sofa, two-person air-jetted, heart-shaped tub, desk area, satellite television, free wireless Internet, mini-refrigerator, and sink. We are excited that two of the rooms are also handicap-accessible. The wooded outdoor views from these rooms are spectacular! These rooms are great for families or long-term business stays. The inn is also available for special events, such as weddings, reunions, and retreats.

The lower level of our Indiana cabin rental offers a Common Room, complete with a lovely fireplace for you to cozy up to and relax. A full kitchen is provided for your use, as well as books, games, and jigsaw puzzles for your enjoyment.

Serenity Suites features 4 larger guest rooms with multiple sleeping arrangements, plus a large meeting/conference room with full kitchen which enables us to accommodate larger groups (church groups, family groups, work groups, scrapbooking groups, quilting groups, sewing groups, workshops, etc.). We’re excited about all the ways that we will be able to serve you better.


Serenity Suite 1

Rate: $135-$145


Enjoy a romantic vacation getaway in this large handicap-accessible suite of approximately 430-sq. ft. featuring a comfortable queen-size bed, private bathroom, and a sofa sleeper. Soak in the two-person, air-jetted tub or lounge in front of the TV. An executive desk area, free wireless Internet, mini-fridge, microwave oven, and a small sink are included. The wooded outdoor view from this room is spectacular.

After a delicious breakfast in our dining room, take a walk in the woods, do some fishing in the pond, or just relax and take in the beautiful, peaceful 37-acre grounds.

Then, venture out to explore the Indiana Amish Country. The towns of Middlebury, Nappanee, Elkhart, Goshen, and Shipshewana offer a wide range of attractions and activities.


Serenity Suite 2

Rate: $135-$145


For a romantic getaway in Indiana, consider spending it in this spacious suite of approximately 430-sq. ft. featuring a comfortable queen-size bed, private bathroom, and a sofa sleeper. Enjoy soaking in the two-person, air-jetted tub or lounging in front of the TV. An executive desk area, free wireless Internet, mini-fridge, microwave oven, and a small sink are included. The wooded, outdoor view from this room is spectacular. A delicious breakfast is provided in our dining room each morning of your stay.

The towns of Middlebury, Nappanee, Elkhart, Goshen, and Shipshewana offer a wide range of attractions and activities for your romantic Indiana vacation adventure.

That Pretty Place has 37 acres of beautiful, peaceful grounds. You can take a walk in the woods, do some fishing in the pond, or just relax and watch the birds and the squirrels.


Serenity Suite 3

Rate: $145-$155


You will enjoy this tastefully decorated room with a comfortable king-sized bed with a full private bathroom. This beautiful room will provide relaxing lodging accommodations during your romantic getaway in Indiana. Two-person air-jetted tub, satellite TV, mini frig, microwave, sink and free wireless Internet service are also provided for your needs and enjoyment. A delicious breakfast is provided in our dining room each morning of your stay. This room also includes a leather sofa bed, desk & chair, and large windows overlooking the beautiful woods and wildlife that may pass by! Our private pond is just a 2-minute walk outside. This building (both floors) are fully handicap accessible.


Serenity Suite 4

Rate: $135-$145


This handicap-accessible room has two queen-sized beds, two-person air-jetted tub, and full private bath. Satellite TV, mini frig, microwave, sink and free wireless Internet are provided for your needs and enjoyment. A delicious breakfast is provided in our dining room each morning of your stay.

THE MAIN HOUSE

Rooms 1 – 4 and the Honeymoon Suite are decorated in their own unique theme. All guestrooms feature a queen bed (some with canopies), private bath, television, air conditioning, and free wireless Internet service. Several rooms overlook the garden, while others have their own private view.

Our accommodations are designed with your comfort in mind. Whether you’re traveling to the Shipshewana, IN area on vacation, taking in a local college football game, or you just need a weekend away, you’ll find That Pretty Place, our bed and breakfast near Nappanee, Indiana to be both comfortable and convenient.

Our Honeymoon Suite offers a romantic haven that features a heart-shaped Jacuzzi, private bath, and affords you a private view of our tranquil pond, woods, or sloping hillside.  Every effort has been made to make this room one you will want to return to time and again to recapture all those special memories.

The details for each room are listed below.  Our prices are for double occupancy.  Extra person charges are $20/person.


Room 1 (Main House)

Rate: $95- $105


Spend an unforgettable weekend getaway in Indiana at That Pretty Place in this popular room. Located on the main level of the inn and featuring a view of the dense woods and garden area, this room will capture you the moment you enter.

You will enjoy the serenity and romance of this lovely room. It offers comfortable lodging accommodations including a queen-sized bed and private bath, perfect after a day of exploring the Shipshewana and Middlebury, IN area or attending a Notre Dame Football game. Satellite TV and free wireless Internet service, and a delicious breakfast are provided for your needs and enjoyment.

 


Room 2 (Main House)

Rate: $95- $105


On the main level of our South Bend area bed and breakfast with a view of the dense woods and garden area, this room at That Pretty Place helps revitalize you.

Room 2 offers relaxing accommodations for an alternative to hotel lodging. You can take a step outside and enjoy the walking trails, the view of the pond, and take a walk or bike ride on the Pumpkinvine Trail.

After a day of exploring the Shipshewana, IN area, you can relax in your comfortable, queen-sized bed and private bath. Satellite TV and free wireless Internet, and a delicious breakfast are provided for your needs and enjoyment.


Room 3 (Main House)

Rate: $95- $105


For your weekend getaway at our secluded Indiana country inn, there is no better place to stay than this room, which has a comfortable, queen-sized bed and private bath provide relaxing lodging accommodations during your Middlebury, IN getaway. Satellite TV and free wireless Internet service are also provided for your needs and enjoyment, and a delicious breakfast is provided in our dining room each morning of your stay.


Room 4 (Main House)

Rate: $95- $105


Reserve this room of That Pretty Place for lodging in the Nappanee, Indiana area. It is a large room that will stir your senses, enveloping you into the peace and quiet. You’ll be sure to request this room time and time again. It has a comfortable, queen-sized bed and private bath. Satellite TV and free wireless Internet service are provided for your needs and enjoyment, and a delicious breakfast is provided in our dining room each morning of your stay.

Our Middlebury, IN B&B offers Amish Country vacation lodging near Notre Dame, Elkhart, Shipshewana, and many wonderful Northern Indiana attractions and activities.

 


Honeymoon Suite (Main House)

Rate: $115-$125


Perfect for a romantic honeymoon in Indiana, this large suite with a two-person Jacuzzi tub immediately grabs your attention upon entering. Come and relax in this great tub! A stand-alone shower and comfortable queen-sized bed complete this lovely room.

While appreciated by the honeymooners, those celebrating special occasions, such as anniversaries and birthdays, will find this romantic suite to be the ideal escape they are seeking for a romantic vacation getaway.

Our honeymoon suite overlooks the beautiful landscape of trees, grass, and the pond at our bed and breakfast inn. Satellite TV and free wireless Internet service and private bath are provided for your needs and enjoyment, and a delicious breakfast is provided in our dining room each morning of your stay.